Bird-in-Hand Lancaster Amish Wet-Bottom Shoofly Pie Variety Pack, Favorite Amish Food

(No reviews yet) Write a Review
Adding to cart… The item has been added

Fresh from Pennsylvania's Amish country, this super variety pack of homemade shoofly pies brings you scrumptious pies from the Bird-in-Hand Bake Shop and the Bird-in-Hand Bakery. Both of these fine establishments have a long history of baking fresh, delicious shoofly pies here in and around the village of Bird-in-Hand, which is situated in the middle of Lancaster County. The pies from the Bake Shop tend to be a bit more heavy with molasses, which makes them a bit more moist and rich-tasting; conversely, the pies from the Bakery tend to be a bit more mild in flavor and somewhat drier. Which is best is really a matter of personal preference, depending on your taste buds! Either way, both of these premium pies go really, really well with a hot coffee, or as the case may be, with a cold chocolate milk.

Fresh fruit delivery: how it works

Shop Online

Browse our online store and select which items you'd like delivered (we also ship our popular grocery and bulk food items!).

Free same-day shipping

Our team packs and ships most orders the same day so you can get your food as quickly as possible.


Enjoy the convenience of farm-picked, nutrient-rich produce shipped directly to your doorstep.

Doing things the right way: our soil-first philosophy

At Kauffman Orchard, we believe in growing and harvesting fruit the right way. For over 100 years, we have believed that cultivating rich soil helps to produce a superior product. That's why we grow fruit that is pesticide-free, healthy, responsibly farmed, and available to be shipped to your doorstep.

Over 100 years
of family farming
Fruit with up to 4 times
more nutrients
Properly cultivated soil
yields healthy fruit