Bird-in-Hand Bakery & Café Homemade, Wet-Bottom Shoofly Pie

$37.67 - $38.39
(2 reviews) Write a Review

Free shipping on every order (to lower 48 states)

Adding to cart… The item has been added
The Bird-in-Hand Bakery and Cafe uses their authentic, old-fashioned, wet-bottom shoofly pie recipe to bake these premium pies right here in the small village of Bird-in-Hand. This 10" shoofly pie gives about 8 servings of this traditional Pennsylvania Dutch dessert with a gooey bottom, cake-like middle and crumb topping. For those of us who have that irresistible sweet tooth, Wet-Bottom Shoofly Pie is a "must have". The shoofly pie is by far the most popular dessert made by the Amish here in Lancaster County! If you are like us, you'll find it's hard to stop with just one slice. Each pie is packed in a white bakery box of heavy cardboard for safe shipping.

2 Reviews Hide Reviews Show Reviews

  • 4
    My son was the recipient

    Posted by Joann Faust on 27th Nov 2023

    He said it was very good

  • 5
    Wet Bottom Shoofly Pie

    Posted by Marion on 7th Aug 2023

    These are by far THE BEST Shoofly Pies I have ever had. Shared some with our neighbors and they raved how good these were. Wanted to freeze and save one pie (purchased two 10") but they will never make it!! No worries, will order more soon!!

Fresh fruit delivery: how it works

Shop Online

Browse our online store and select which items you'd like delivered (we also ship our popular grocery and bulk food items!).

Free same-day shipping

Our team packs and ships most orders the same day so you can get your food as quickly as possible.


Enjoy the convenience of farm-picked, nutrient-rich produce shipped directly to your doorstep.

Doing things the right way: our soil-first philosophy

At Kauffman Orchard, we believe in growing and harvesting fruit the right way. For over 100 years, we have believed that cultivating rich soil helps to produce a superior product. That's why we grow fruit that is pesticide-free, healthy, responsibly farmed, and available to be shipped to your doorstep.

Over 100 years
of family farming
Fruit with up to 4 times
more nutrients
Properly cultivated soil
yields healthy fruit